The Challenge

  • Concern about seismic stability of oil storage tank farms
  • Kawasaki Refinery situated in highly seismic area on reclaimed land
  • Original foundation design lacks consideration for earthquake loads

In the early 1970’s, TONEN Corporation became concerned with the seismic stability of three large oil storage tank farms at their Kawasaki Refinery. The refinery is located in a high seismically active region. The entire facility was constructed over reclaimed land made by sedimenting sand and silt dredged from Tokyo Bay. The original foundation design did not consider earthquake loads.

The Solution

TONEN contacted Professor T. William Lambe who had consulted on the original development of the site. Working as Technical Manager for T. William Lambe Associates, Dr. Allen Marr was assigned Project Manager for this work. After an initial assessment of the site conditions, the Lambe team determined that conventional approaches to foundation design would be very costly and might not result in a corresponding improvement in safety. Dr. Marr assembled a team of experts to develop a risk-based methodology to assess the risk created by earthquake shaking. That methodology included an evaluation of historical regional seismicity, development of a site-specific seismic intensity curve, and development of event and fault trees to determine which seismic related events and which failure modes contributed to overall risk.

Probabilistic analyses were conducted to determine overall risk for the site, where risk was measured as both a probability of failure and a cost of the consequences. The main cause of risk was identified to be failure of multiple tanks due to deformation of their foundations from earthquake shaking. The most cost effective means of risk reduction proved to be lowering the ground water level within the hydraulic fill. The methodology was successfully applied to three sites at a cost savings of $60 million compared to more conventional methods.

Services Provided

Seismic Assessment

Developed a risk based methodology to assess the risk created by earthquake shaking

Risk Analysis

Probabilistic analyses conducted to determine overall risk for the site

Risk Reduction

Identifying main cause of risk and offering the client the most cost effective solution

Related Projects

GEOPROJECT_TVA Risk

Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA)

Value Delivered:

Using risk monitoring to help manage major risks for
public safety
Automatically notify required staff on issues and problem
solve quickly and efficiently
GEOPROJECT_Fukushima

Fukushima Nuclear Power Plant

Value Delivered:

Developed risk register, identifying risks and their
potential causes, impacts, and mitigation measures
Performed modeling to evaluate design feasibility
and risks
GEOPROJECT_Oosterschelde

Oosterschelde

Value Delivered:

Evaluated flood barrier design, predicted displacement
Innovative solutions addressed liquefaction and piping
concerns
Pioneered extensive geosynthetic use for foundation
protection

Ready to Speak
with our
Experts